Afghanistan’s secret prostitutes
You never have to wander far from your front door in Kabul to be confronted by the dire poverty in a city where billions have been spent in foreign aid over the past decade of occupation by the west. Where an entire sub-economy has grown up around the semi-permanent presence of foreign NGOs.
You will see the beggars somehow surviving in the middle of traffic-choked streets (this city has some of the worst air-pollution on the planet) pleading with their missing body parts , appealing for alms, mouthing words that can never be heard above the din of the traffic at a near standstill in the freezing crisp air.
Or the widows, invisible in their burkhas, who sit in the snow at the roadsides, holding babies swaddled, but still coughing in the sub-zero air, for hour after hour after hour. They too, hope for the odd Afghani from generous passers-by.
Or get up early and go to the known places where they gather. Men, often hundreds of them, desperate for work of any kind for perhaps a dollar or two per day – maybe 100 Afghanis in their pockets after 10 or 12 hours hard labour in sub-zero conditions. Anything’s considered. No, change that. Anything’s grabbed with both hands unconsidered.
But behind closed doors of houses, reasonably well-to-do houses, there is also quiet despair.
In a Kabul suburb we have come to a woman’s house. We’ll call her Habiba. She’s playing with her daughter on the carpet, a toddler. There’s a small but modern flatscreen TV in the corner. A house of several bedrooms. In her headscarf and jeans she is very westernised by Afghan standards. On several occasions Channel 4 News meets Habiba and films and talks to her, with her husband not present. Even meeting an Afghan woman at all in her home would be quite unthinkable in most parts of this country and most of this city too – let alone doing so with no husband in the room.
But what we shall witness in this house goes so far beyond the norms of Afghanistan’s conservative society – so far beyond the norms of British society come to that – it is hard to find words to frame it.
Habiba, in her late 20s, is a schoolteacher. Her husband, a civil-servant. Or at least they were.
Some months back her husband’s epilepsy and other health problems forced him to leave his job, he said. And then he took to drink. And he also took to beating Habiba up if she declined to do his bidding.
By any standards in any society that bidding is extraordinary. He has forced her to leave the classroom and become a prostitute. He, the husband, is now also the pimp.
“I hate this life,” she says, tears rolling down her cheeks. “Right now I hate myself and my husband. I think I am the worst person in the world. It is horrible. And what about my daughter?”
She cries uncontrollably. “What kind of example – what kind of role model am I for her? But if I don’t do this I will get beaten.”
And you do not have to tell Habiba that in Afghanistan, if you leave your husband then you leave your children too and there will be no coming back and no safety net at all, financially. And your life and safety will be in real jeopardy. Habiba is trapped and Habiba knows it.
The motive for this couple in allowing us to film them and their extreme means of maintaining their income, is curious. They both think that if there is publicity in the west about this kind of thing and the lack of any kind of real support for people too ill to work, then things will somehow improve. It seems a deeply far-fetched, not least in a world where that same west is hell-bent on getting out of its Afghan mire as fast as it possibly can.
“I want her to go back to teaching. I want to get treatment and go back to work myself.” Says her husband in one breath. But in the next, he turns to Habiba and shouts:
“Get this place ready – we’ve got guests arriving.”
And Habiba will – must – obey. She must prepare the food and the tea. Tidy the front room to receive the guests. Make sure that everything is in order in the room behind the curtain where, after a little cursory chat and the exchange of a wad of Afghanis given to the husband (not to her) she will be taken by the hand by one of two men come to visit.
Behind that curtain in a room used for the business, she will make more money in a little over eight minutes, than she will in two weeks in the classroom. Except she won’t of course. the cash never was – never will be – given to her.
When the client returns to sit down and take a little more tea, she will follow meekly and sit too, in her own home, with the husband she now says she hates.
Then there will be laughter as the husband, the cliient and his friend pass an enjoyable afternoon. Habiba will offer food. She will offer and pour green tea. She will say nothing. And after twenty minutes or so, warm handshakes from the two visiting men for the pimp. Then a cursory slap of Habiba’s feebly proffered hand, from the punter – a sort of horizontal high-five, without the joy and happiness. And they are gone, out into the snow and another item of this secret business has been transacted.
She will now clear up the food and do the dishes. And only then will she confront her husband, all of it captured on the camera we have left running – with their agreement – in a corner of the room.
“Look at you – you just sit there and don’t say a thing. Say something – for God’s sake!! How can we go on living like this? You should be scared – God is watching you and you should be really scared.”
Her husband – her pimp – just sits there and says nothing it all.
A little later in the day they will go out shopping. They will trudge through the snow to the bazaar close by. He, carrying their daughter. She, dutifully walking a couple of faces behind her man as tradition demands, and clad in the full blue burkha one sees so much in Kabul. Just another Afghan family. Outside they follow the customs, culture, traditions. Indoors in secret, they are all obliterated for money, but at huge cost.
Read more from Alex – follow @alextomo on Twitter.



There are 31 comments on this post
No words
This has shocked me deeply poor lady how evil is her so called husband how could he make her do this? I am so very sad for this lady.
The husband’s actions in pimping his wife are reprehensible. So too are yours, in reporting this story without protecting the women. Channel 4 News knows well that by showing the faces of these women you may well be condemning them to death in conservative Afghanistan. No doubt they signed a release, but those niceties will have little meaning should they find themselves in the hands of a conservative court in Afghanistan, to say nothing of a mob.
Are there any organisations working to help these women in Kabul?
I notice you have blurred the face of the child on the website phote, but in your broadcast just now on UK TV you showed both the mother (prostitued by her husband) and the son. What of the rights of this child? What protection have you offered him. Or his mother, when she is shown as clearly identifiable in conservative Afghanistan. Is she not doubly victimized?
I listen to Radio 4 news and find myself often distracted. I always try to watch Channel 4 News, I rate and respect the journalism but, you know, I find myself getting distracted with everyday early evening stuff – until last night. Alex Thomson’s reports from Afghanistan last night and tonight were examples of profound journalism. His style was thorough, the report and filming as if I was there yet he was unobtrusive and non-judgemental.
I rarely write on these things but I searched the site until I found somewhere that I could record this.
Thank you for such quality journalism C4 News team
There are shed loads of forced prostitutes in every European and American city as well. This report just stereotypes Afghan men negatively. We know that things are desperate for ordinary people in Kabul but you could report this without smearing Afghans and Muslims.
Hello
As a teacher i was very shocked to see the report
Is there something ,some help.money we can give her ,Or from the NUT my union, a teaching union surely to get her and her daughter away from her pimp
How awful, the poor woman is no different to me, yet I dont have to sell my body to feed my family. I admire her resilience!!!
What a sad comment on a society that far from being saved and redeemed by western intervention, finds itself plunged into new depths of degredation and humiliation. From what was once one of my favourite destinations to visit, a wonderful and charming country, to a wreck, dependant on vast amounts of aid. This news report only illustrates how far and all embracing that fall has been
Hypocrisy in it’s most ugly form. In Afghanistan they use religion as an excuse to carry out such horrendous acts, if these men that rule the country and the women that reside there were as modest and as righteous as they claim to be then they would never stoop to such a low level. If Islam was so important to them then this would not be happening. It shows that these men are powerless, regardless of the patriarchy and the ‘power’ they yield, because they still have to depend on a woman.
@Anon30 – definitely the most stupid thing I have read this week!
I have watched the report on the channel and it was so frustrating and sad, I am so angry from the husband he is very humiliating person , he does not respect his wife neither god.
frankly it was the first time for me to cry during watching TV.
by the way I am 22 years old man.
please tell me if I can do any help, and I would like to join any woman rights organization.
I saw this on the programme and was extremely shocked by it and just wanted to commend you on this stellar reporting. I hope the series is receiving a wide audience.
First of all i would like to thank you for addressing these kind of issues which is representing one of thousands problems poor people of Afghanistan are facing every singal day.This is the result of 10 years corrupt government,backed by the western pollitaions.Billions of dollars, which has been donated by the international funds,have been looted by these crooks who had nothing before they come to power and now they have several houses ,not only in Afghanistan, but in Dubai and the western countries.Corruption is the main reason for continuance war in this country.Some one has to do something about it before it is too late otherwise the story of middle east could bee repeated in Afghanistan.
Unless and until women fight for themselves this situation will remain in many other countries too. A forced life of prostitution is no less better then dead. One must get this clear in her heart and head that you, yourself should come first only then u can look after ur kids and family. A bullet might hurt for a minute or so but getting raped will always every second till u r alive. Choice is urs.
Hi,
I did watch the channel 4′s news and especially the Afghanis secret prostitute piece! Although it was good to know the poverty and difficult life that people live in Afghanistan, nevertheless, your reporter (Alex) exceeded the limit. To talk about prostitution is onething but to record (in secret!) and show the faces of those two men who were paying her through her husband to have sex with her was not only disgusting and immoral scene but it was dangerous act! One thing I’m sure,according to Afghan culture, if the tribe of that man who was selling his wife (or even the his poor wife’s trib) discover, god forbid, this report(through internet or another way)I’m definitely sure that the only thing they will do is: murdering the whole family! so, I want to know only one thing from the channel four news editor: would you take the responsibility, in case, if they murder that woman or her husband or both of them? Because you’re taking the credit of this piece of film, so,you must also take the responsilibty that comes along with it. I know you want to increase your rating, but this is simply nothing but: unethical journalism. thanks.
I really can not understand that a husband could to this to his partner.
The hell that woman is enduring makes me feel ill.
I don’t admit that I know all there is about Islamic culture,however this is so wrong.
This is not about culture or islam, its about bad man, greed and laziness, bad government….. Aid and money will not help.
Alex,
Afghanistan was always a poor country.
But every time it has been invaded it has got much, much worse.
“Charlie Wilson’s War” was “successful” indeed. Well done, Bush2, Blair, and all the rest of the war criminals who made this kind of horror more likely.
Why should anyone in the East believe ANYTHING the West says about “democracy” and “prosperity”?
Shame on the people who caused these conditions, not on the victims. Shame on the Western men of power who triggered it then walked away like the cowards they have always been and always will be.
SO FAKE !!!
I have lived in Afghanistan for a long time, and I have never even heard of such thing that an Afghan husband will do this to his wife!
In Afghanistan a man will loose his life but wont let anyone see even his wife’s face, his women is everything for him. they are forcing their women to wear Burqa and hiding them. This report is totally fake and totally unprofessional.
I too have deep suspicions about this piece which I’ve never done before whilst watching C4 News. I felt as though it were staged, especially near the end of the report when the woman was supposedly scolding her husband but was smiling slightly, looking at the camera and it made me feel uneasy. I don’t know what to make of it-and I can’t believe the best journos on UK TV would fake such a thing? Unless you want to show the appalling situation but protect real people in which case why not just declare you are using actors?
I suggest you think again.. There are many aspects which are very real and still ignored and never told but still happens. Men in these areas keep and take their woman just as an object.
“Shame on the people who caused these conditions, not on the victims. Shame on the Western men of power who triggered it then walked away like the cowards they have always been and always will be.”
This piece was sensationalist and one-sided reporting which gives leaves a misleading impression. It is possible to make anywhere and its people look bad by filming the pimps operating there and there are pimps in every city in the world not just Kabul.
Your report was very pogniant and shocking.
I am however very concerned about the safety of the child and her mother.
looks like channel 4 has been taken for a lot of money by a very clever con team. No way would any of them want it to be made public, if true. The penalty for all 4 of them would be death under Islamic law. If the wives family did not get husband first. Although not Muslim myself, I speak from the Experience of living in Muslim family owned house for 20 years in the uk.
“I have lived in Afghanistan for a long time, and I have never even heard of such thing that an Afghan husband will do this to his wife!”
I am from Afghanistan, by denying the facts we can not change them. It is the grim portray of this country whether you like it or not. There have been, and there are thousands of these kind men and women who do the same business willingly or forced. It does not have to be used against any one. We always blame others for our own shortcomings. Neither west nor our neighbors have to be blamed. the blames should be put on us. Every single one of us have misused the resources poured by west in this country. We are the ones who made secret deals with the landlords to increase the rate of luxuries houses, without think for a minute what might happen to those who can not afford to rent a single room building and thousands of many other examples of selfishness, greed, dishonesty, theft and so on…. I am responsible and all other citizen of this country are responsible for the plight of this couple and many others….
I agree with Evelyn who said ‘pimps are every city in the world not just kabul’ so, why are just making this piece sensationalist to boost your (MR Alex) ratings!
having read all the above comments, it came to mind that this piece of evidnece represens the current situation of life for all mainly for women in Afghanistan and all poor countries.
what is the solution:
1st you need to know what is going on and then to seek cure!
thanks form channel 4 which brought this into light to amke people aware of such plights and to find a slution for it.
WOMEN’S RIGHT
ALL WOMEN AROUND THE WORLD NEEDS TO UNITE AND FIGHT FOR THEIR RIGHTS….
just want to say unbelievable