Haiti: no doctor, no medicine, no hope
I think he’ll die. A sweet man, a pastor who’s church had collapsed upon him. Here he is lying down.
His mangled right hand had been traumatically damaged in the earthquake. His arm is vastly swollen and I suspect gangrene. He is still able to converse.
His body is a mass of suppurating sores. He has had no medical attention since the quake and his wife lies buried beneath their house, which engulfed her at the same moment that his church came down.
His sheer dignity in grief seems both to allow him to understand that he will die, and to allow him to be frightened.
We talk in difficult French. I try to see whether it might be possible to find someone with a car that still runs and still has petrol, to get him to hospital.
But neither he nor I know whether the hospital is still standing – and even if it has, whether it has drugs or anti-sceptic bandages.
The pastor is on a bedspread out in the open air, flat on the concrete surface of a small basketball pitch.
Nearby, lying on what seems to be the upside down roof of an old pick up truck, a middle aged woman with an horrific wound on the left hand side of her head.
The eye completely overwhelmed by a huge mound of knotted flesh – again poison seems to have set in, and she needs help desperately. Another woman, younger, has a gaping wound in her leg. No doctor, no medicine, no hope.
Every house on the hillside above and below has been smashed and mangled. In all there are 306 souls in the camp. The bodies of the people these people loved and lived with, are still inside, the stench is utterly overwhelming.
An old woman emerges from a corrugated shed, enveloped in dust. She is a hundred feet below me. She thrusts three fingers in the air at me, pleads, her arms thrown asunder, and then clenches her nose. She and I know of what she signals.
Three people are dead in her house, almost certainly the three people she loved most, lived with longest. She wants them out, disposed off.
She is distracted with utter grief and desolation. Her life is over. She might only be sixty, but what can console her, what can reconnect her with what was?
I had only found my way to the camp by chance. We had passed a water truck with a vast orderly queue. I had got talking to a younger woman, Anguine.
Her friend standing next to her was seven months pregnant. She herself had three children under eight. Both had had their houses wiped out by the earthquake. So I asked if we might visit what had been here home and where the now slept.
There wasn’t a square inch of the basketball court to spare. The pastor was surrounded by women who might have been his sisters or neighbours fanning him with rags.
It wasn’t just that no doctor or nurse had been here – no single official NGO, media, GI nor anyone else had been here in the five days since the quake. And the story was just the same if not worse in the next camp 100 meters down the hill.
Here more than a thousand people crammed into an area no bigger that the penalty area of a football pitch. Again no single official had visited and needs were critical. Water, medicines, medical attention, and food.
But we as left, with our guilt and incapacity and our complete helplessness in our hearts, we suddenly saw a team of evaluators, a man in a white t-shirt from the UN Organization for Migrant Peoples – God lives!
And on this day he is alive and struggling in Haiti in the form of the United Nations and so many large and small people’s organisations, NGOs, trying to transform your money into these victims life lines.
White T-Shirt has a lady in pink with him, armed with a clipboard, a yellow pad, and illegible writing. Spontaneous committee leaders representing the camp give her the details.
But there’s another man, and he turns out to be the first official of any rank in Haiti’s governance that we have met. He is one of the only two district mayors in Port-au-Prince to have survived the quake – the other five are feared dead.
He’s a focused man, by chance, in what once was real life, he was an architect and civil engineer. He’s dynamic in this unremitting hell.
His own house has collapsed, but his mayoral white 4X4 has survived and his shirt is clean and pressed. He’s on the starting block of recovery.
We take the mayor, the lady in pink, and white t-shirt to the Pastor’s camp. The twenty dollars I had given for transport seems to have removed them. To where I have no idea – there is nowhere here.
The mayor meets, greets, moves among the dispossessed pleading with them to wait for what he knows he cannot deliver.
He tells me that he has discovered that prisoners from the nearby jail that spewed its inmates during the quake, have looted even what little these people had.
The mayor is going to a meeting with the UN. If he feels hopeless he does not show it.
He’s one of two in a city with 100,000 dead, and a million wounded and homeless, but he and the still small band of NGOs are a beginning, a still small ember of hope.
Related posts:


There are 64 comments on this post
Was listening to RTE Radio 1 this morning (Pat Kenny Show) and he interviewed a staff member in a fully equipped orthopaedic hospital 75 miles outside Port au Prince. They have teams of surgeons standing by to treat the injured and despite repeated pleas to (I think) the US military to transport patients to them by helicopter (which would take 30 mins) so far they have received only 14 patients.
Although the aid – food, water and medical – getting through is a fraction of what is needed, there are some medical staff getting into PAP. The Haiti Hospital Appeal is based in Cap-Haitien, in the north, and has sent an ambulance in as an emergency response. Patients willbe returned to their barely finished hospital, and further supplies will be sent to the capital. Follow the latest news as it happens on their blog, and if you haven’t yet, DONATE NOW. But remember, a real recovery for Haiti will mean sustained interest and support from the whole world.
Seems like a mission completely impossible. And yet, people are trying. One must admire them, it would be so easy to just give up hope.
Apart from hurricanes and Haiti had four in 2009 alone, we must also remember the mud slides due to relentless logging. These killer slides were a direct result of monsoon rain.
U.S. companies have wiped out a natural and very valuable resource, the countries tree’s. There are hardly any left on the island and that is because the U.S. has once again taken advantage of the weak, leaving a very poor local population, to build their lives on unstable ground.After slaves, dictators, armed conflicts and natural disasters, poor Haiti sits comfortably next to the richest. One would presume, with Cuba being too close for comfort, that the U.S. administration would have wanted the opposite. Port-au-Prince is 727 miles from La Habana and a 172 miles, from the nearest Cuban coastline. The Haitian capital, is less than 700 miles from the southern tip of Florida.Haiti, is the poorest country in the western hemisphere, one of the 50 poorest independent States in the world. The United States of America, should be pouring immediate billions and not millions, into this earthquake relief effort.I’m sure that many U.S. citzens would agree, it’s just that many aren’t enough.
adzmundo CND
Every time I turn on the TV news, I see yet another hack who has got in to Haiti (yourself and Ms. Smith being but the latest examples), bleating about supplies, rescue workers and doctors… not being able to get in!!
Given the obvious drastic physical limits on the amount of people and goods that can be delivered to Haiti, every hack/crew getting in clearly means a doctor/aid worker not getting in.
If you really do have – and I quote – “guilt and incapacity and complete helplessness in our hearts”, I suggest that you and a good many other hacks get out and leave the precious room and resources for infinitely more capable and helpful people.
One hack plus small crew per country is perfectly sufficient in these precious early days.
good point
If Haiti was full of TBTF Banks – things would have moved quicker – but its not – The US has made it a very poor country – now aid is slow – one US TV pesronality said Haiti should not be helped – becuse Obama was making political capital out of it – how sick can one get . I agree – why do not Goverments pour Billions into this disaster like they did for the Banks – and make sure at least those who survive have a living – no – they prefer to let the Public help variuos aid Agencies – pity this approach was not operative for the banking crisis when it only took some days for US alone to pour 750Billion into the Banks – just shows waht Capitaism thinks of People – a very expendable commodity .
The coordination of US/NGO logistic operation which is being undertaken at the moment is in Haiti is close to impossible. Had you ever been there, as I have, you would understand it would have been enormous task even without the Earthquake. The reports are all harrowing and end up with the same bottom line, no one is doing enough. We rely on Channel 4 for real news. May we have a report on the Operational coordination and the logistic complexities involved of the relief op by a visit to the command and control centre of the effort. Whilst many become indignant with “not enough is being done” it should be rememberd that our lines of communication in the UK have been laid to waste for a week by 6 inches of snow. Soon the priorites will be changing from rescue to the provision of fresh water to prevent a Cholera outbreak which could take many more thousands of lives. It must be rememberd that the lives and safety of the Aid Workers must remain paramount and that law and order must be in place for them to work effectively.
I agree with the gentleman from CND that U.S. corporations have wiped out Haiti’s trees leaving the country vulnerable to the effects of slides and earthquakes and I agree the U.S. should be pouring in billions into relief and to rebuild the infrastructure of this, the poorest nation in the western hemisphere … a country which U.S. interests have totally exploited. I DO NOT agree with the premise that Cuba has not been responsive. Cuba has trained some 6,000 doctors in Haiti since 1998 and 400 were on hand when the quake hit. 152 of them were available to work with the 37 surgeons sent from Cuba along with a full field hospital less than 24 hours after the quake. Hours later 30 more doctors arrived with additional medical supplies. 1000 victims were operated on or treated. The Cubans (their Henry Reeve Brigade – disaster relief specialists) were FIRST on the scene but they get no credit. Memories of New Orleans when, in the aftermath of Katrina, Cuba offered 1600 members of the brigade … it was an offer to which the U.S. government never responded. Today, Fox News reports that the Cubans “had not offered aid”. Unbelievable.
The really bad thing about Fox is so many in US watch it and believe it- a statement like that – Re Cubans – only fosters hate and misundersatnding . .
Why dont you and channel4 put your mike downs and camera down and start running the show. stop making noise and let the people who are trying their best at short notice under terrible circumstances dow what they are trained to do. how much has channel 4 donated, how much are you doing apart from making noise. help not impair.
Please stop this unrelenting coverage. I cannot imagine that poor man from the UM being able to concentrate on the task at hand when he has to face a prime-time news interview. Jon Snow and then who, and then perhaps NPR from the US and then? I would rather see you, Sara Smith and others handing out food and water to the victims.
What ridiculous comments by all the anti-media brigade! If the media was not there we would not know that help was needed so much. I’m sure Jon and his colleagues are desperate to ‘muck in’ and help handing out food and water, but they are trained professional journalists and know that they are best placed to tell the wider world what is happening.
Do we really need 100′s of foreign journalists out there in Port-Au-Prince?
It’s one thing covering such a terrible disaster but these ‘foreigners’ must be being fed out there and with thousands going hungry, even just one UNNECESSARY mouth to feed, verging on the obscene when all they do is keep telling US how the Hiatians are starving to death?
So how you gonna now what’s happening outside you fence then???
It’s heartbreaking to watch these reports.
It is hard sitting here to understand how journalists from around the world can reach people but aid cannot. The poor, suffering souls must be sick of the sight of TV cameras when all they want is food, water and medicine.
I’m the last to criticise journalists but it does seem a waste of scarce fuel and resources to be filming from helicopters
I’m sorry but am I the only person in the UK who is appalled at the presumed number of journalists in Haiti? How many in John Snow’s team? How many from the BBC. And ITV I imagine. What about the French as their former colony. The Americans? Probaly countless newspapers too. Yes of course we all need to know what is going on. Not least so we will be moved to contribute to disaster funds. But we don’t need this many there. What Haiti needs now is doctors, nurses, builders, drivers, cooks and so on.
Perhaps the journalists are out there digging with their bear hands whilst off air. How otherwise can they justify their use of resources in a stricken country?
If it wasn’t for the journalists, we wouldn’t be seeing the scale of this disaster. They’re not on a golden beach holiday, although could choose to be, no, they are in a very volatile dangerous place trying to keep the world informed of the plight of these people and, encourage people to donate/help however they can,
We need to thank these people, not criticise them.
Jon Snow needs to show a bit more empathy. Yesterday he asked the people of haiti who where praying where god was when this earthquake happened. Its his choice not to believe in god but its bad manners to ridicule peoples beliefs at a time like this especially if that belief in god is the main thing that’s giving them strength and hope during this time. His report was offensive and down right rude and he should apologize for his callous attitude.
If He asked people parying where god was – I agree that was insensitive – one of US Evangelicals went a good deal furtehr – He [ Pat Robertson ] said the earthquke happened because the Hiatainas were devil worshippers – The US is a fine country – in many ways – but it sure has its adequte quota of screwballs .
Although I appreciate Jon’s coverage of the situation, I think that the total media coverage of the situation is, in itself, impacting the relief effort.
If you take the number of TV crews across all the world-wide channels the cost in resources must be significant, and they are all basically reporting the same information.
Wouldn’t it be possible to almost consider a “bidding system” (rather like the football premier league) where one channel gets the rights to cover disasters over a year and the fees paid go to relief agencies.
It’s a basic idea, but after watching reporter after reporter walking past (almost the same) families effected by disasters there must be a better way of TV/Radio channels helping the people.
one feels helpless,and can only admire the efforts of those on the ground.i cant help wondering where a place can be found for people to bury their dead,and what happens to those who have died and no relative can be found.who documents these things for any surviving relatives at a later date.
also would it be possible to set up field hospitals under canvas?
If it is true there is an orthopaedic hospital 75miles away in haiti ready to take casulties,why aren’t more people being flown there?
Watched C4 news tonight. In final sequence with JS & SS I was struck that this is momentus current reporting, on a par with “I counted them out and I counted them in”. Just a short note to say congratulations and thank you.
Mr Snow, your passionate and erudite comments are most welcome in an every increasing world of sound bites and 2nd rate reporting. Thank you so much for your commitment to sending information that is truthful and compassionate, told with humilty and without artifice. I salute you and Channel 4 for the best news programme by a mile.
I second that comment too.
What can I do??Money is not enough.I want to go and be hands on helping the people of Haiti, rather than just talking about it.
Along with the wish, shared by many others, to give hands on aid, I also wonder why journalists + crews can with seeming ease reach the desperate ,whereas the much needed aid does not.
as the journalists and reproters seem to get around Haiti with greater ease and in greater numbers than the rescue services, couldn’t they be sent out with supplies of anaesthetics, etc?
Could Jon Snow tell us how many reporters it takes to cover a disaster like this? How many seats have been wasted on emergency flights carrying journo’s? Where are they getting their food and water from when thousands are struggling to survive?
Correct me if I’m wrong but isn’t Haiti connected to the Dominician Republic, if so why arn’t aid flights flooding into there instead of tourists going on holiday? How many more useless politicians are we going to see screwing up the airport.
KJ
I have kept up-to-date with events in Haiti and to be honest, I’m not optimistic about the American interference……Obama needs to stop his ‘symbolic/historic’ speeches and back them up with action/ not bother at all.
If they want to paint themselves as Haiti’s saviours, they should stop diverting flights to the Dominican Republic…Ditto the UN…. Pissed off with Ban Ki-Moon about his ‘Haitains should wait’ comments. Haiti has been waiting for far too long.
Aristide anyone???
I wish people – and I am afraid I have to say that Jon Snow is one of them – were not so quick to pass judgment on the agencies, who are deemed to slow in their response. Lisa Jardine’s wonderfully thoughtful piece on a separate topic on the challenge of delivering supplies (e.g. rock salt) for public use and how public perceptions – informed by their experience of modern supermarket supply chains – has very high expectations on what is possible. In Haiti, with no diesel, no port and poor airport facilities, perhaps John should listen to Lisa and reflect a little before his next report.
In this sea of despair one can only wonder how the Haitians will ever recover from it…
Thank you, Jon, and all best to the crew. You’re increasing our understanding – together with some excellent letters in today’s Guardian – and that matters. Stay safe.
Today on CNN, Russell Honore, commander of Joint Task Force-Katrina, said in a telephone interview. “I think we need to move faster and to use every military capability we’ve got.” He claimed that U.S. military units are capable of parachuting people and equipment onto a roadway near the capital and turning it into a landing strip fit for a cargo plane in a day. He recommended creating multiple airstrips this way. Most importantly, he said that concerns about security conducting food drops should not take precedence over getting supplies to people quickly. He concluded by saying, “when you have people dying, getting food and water on the ground should end any talk of security,”
I have no doubt that a country capable of televising the ‘Shock and Awe’ burning of Baghdad throughout the world could drop many tons of food and water over Haiti with fewer problems of ‘security’ than were perpetrated in Iraq over the last ten years.
Some French aid crews have said that the American control of the runway is one of the biggest stumbling blocks.For example they had portable hospitals on board but were held up inthe sky in favour of US military equipment. and things like security issues of looking after Clinton’s entourage so that they can get the photos for the folks back home must get in the way of aid effort? Have you found that Jon?
DEC are taking in all this cash – they allocate it on an undisclosed basis to 13 ‘members’ – some of whom seem to have little relevance and less capability than others.
Accountabilty is non-existant, activity is uncoordinated and in many cases overlapping and frankly in Haiti will be totally overshadowed by US military and conscript effort.
Sadly too any report on the ‘members’ activity, shrouded in secrecy, will not appear for many months.
This is no way to use public donations made in good faith. The ‘members’ admit that no more than 80% of funds will be used in the emergency zone and we have no idea how that is spent.
Coordination is critical as you said tonight and having small teams buzzing about on their own un-audited agenda is not the way.
Who could fail to be touched to the core by what we have witnessed in Haiti over the past few days? You, John, are able to be there and see for yourself and perform some small, inadequate, but oh so necessary acts of mercy. But above all, to let the plight of these people be known to the world, even if there is very little we can do. Since 1992, my wife and I have worked amongst even poorer people than the Haitians, in a remote village in Cameroon, Africa. We are currently on home leave in Scotland because of the stresses of living and working amongst extreme poverty. Apart from a famine one year and a cholera epidemic another time, we have not seen suffering on the scale caused by an earthquake, hurricane or tsunami, but my heart bleeds for the Haitian people all the same.
(I have written quite a bit more, not realising that it would be cut off at 1200 chars. Is there anywhere I can post the rest?)
It gave me some hope when I saw Jon Snow with the Haitian people this evening. Those people have such dignity in the face of all their are suffering.
I question whether Channel 4 should be sending three journalists (plus carmera and sound people) to Haiti. Would not one be able to report on the key points and the saved money either donated to the disaster relief or pay for doctors and nurses to accompany the lone journalists?
Thanks Jon, Sarah and Jonathon for high lighting the unseen plights of those who would be otherwise unseen .
Shopping List.
Water.
Bags of IV fluids/gelofusin and cannulae.
Suturing material./ scalpels of all sizes.
Broad spectrum antibiotics. oral and IV.
Gauze swabs in abundance.
Bandages/ tape.
Antiseptic.
Plastering material.
Morphine, hydrocortisone, adrenaline , piriton.
O2 and masks.
Surgeons for amputation .
Nurses.
Generators and large batteries.
Several of us seem to have hit on the same theme, that it is uncomfortable to see so many resources in Haiti being used by journalists.
Aid agencies will say they need the coverage – it’s what creates the atmosphere that leads to such massive public donations.
But does every single news organisation need to be there mob handed?
Maybe it’s time for the leading companies to get together to form a disaster team that would provide them all with coverage. It would be fraught with problems and would have to be independent so it could ask the awkward questions. But it must be preferable to hundreds of journalists using up fuel, food and water
In some ways it is hard to imagine how a Reurers type operation could satisfy both Fox News and Channel 4 but we are always asking our politicians to tackle difficult problems, so why not the media?
At present I wish I could come along with a suitcase full of IV fluids , giving sets,assortment of medications , suture materials etc and the help with the support of constructive good will,.. how many more feel like this?
Mark Austin on the other side is showing us the difference made to just a few lives with help. they need . Jon is showing us, what is needed and the necessary support which is being given in the form of plane fulls of aid,Sarah is highlighting the problem of distribution and the need to remove those trying to steal aid.
Why no helicopters and air drops?
France is being stopped from helping by diplomats.
A few still show what positive action they can come up with.
Stop squabbling and help.. all those who are able.
The saddest aspect after all the dreadful sufferring is to know that these people will be ripped off again by the US and others whose only long term interest is in their own financial profit. Look at their poverty and you see where western wealth has come from.
Everyone accepts it is a dreadful tragedy. Reporters can get there and assail us with dreadful pictures.Aid can get there.
The main problem is that somehow the Americans have taken charge and we all should know by now they cant run a p*ss up in a brewery
I find the growing anti-American feeling disappointing. Some are accusing them of being too bossy and interfering too much, while others berate them for not doing more.
I may be completely naive but I am inclined to take President Obama at his word. He has a good humanitarian track record.
And I can see no reason why America should be trying to block aid reaching the Haitians.
Maybe those of us sitting a few thousand miles away and only seeing a glimpse of what is happening on our TV, should not be too quick to condemn, no matter how frustratiting it might seem.
i can’t argue with your blog .I don’t have anti american feelings at all .I believe we need the Americans both for their strength and numbers.I commented that they can’t organise anything.Take iraq and afghanistan, now Haiti.
I saw their organisation many years ago when i spent a week on one of their destroyers in an exchange visit.Their firepower and caperbilities were awsome, even then, but their actual organisation was cr*p compared with the RN
Im sure Obama is doing a s much as he can to help Haitians- its the least the US can do after all the expolitation – – but to say that he has a good humnaitarian track record just does not stand up – he is at presnt Blockading the West Bank and Gaza of essential supplies to try to rebuild after lasts uears war – including medical supplies – which are costing lives – not to mention the bombings in Afhganistan – his record is far from humanitarian.
It is highly commendable for people like Jon Snow to get into Haiti and report about the crisis. We need this information coz as the Bible puts it ‘without knowledge people perish. Carry on Mr Snow. As people see the extent of this problem, may those with tight fists loosen them and donate money to help those in need.
Not so sure of that as his carbon footprint gets as big as his tan
The sovereign State of Haiti has it’s own disaster management system, headed by the Directorate for Civil Protection. Over the past few years, international organisations and NGOs have supported the strenghtening of this institution and disaster response mechanisms.
The central DPC carries out its mandate with “decentralised” institutions at the department and municipal levels, and in some instance down to the community level.
This catastrophe is unlike any other event the country has experienced in the last few years. The recent history of Haiti has seen a greater number of flooding, cyclone and landslide disasters.
Sadly, it was to be expected that in the face of such an event, the disaster management authorities would be overwhelmed. Coud you however report on what has been done so far by official disaster management authorities and the work carried out by the very “first responders”, which are the neighbours, community/religious groups, and in some instances existing local civil protection committees?
Your reporter Jon Snow’s repeated badgering of aid agency senior staff ‘Who is co-ordinating the efforts?’, repeated about five times, is one of the most miserable sights in C4′s news. This not the usual ‘find somebody to blame’ game in the London studio, usual involving a hapless politician. It would be best Jon Snow came back and left those fighting to help the Haitians alone. His reports don’t help anybody. Publicity for the Haitians’ plight? Who does he think he is? Jeremy Paxman? And sneeringly counting the Chinook helicopters at the airport? What is his point?
I don’t agree,there has to be leadership to get things done,in any situation there will emege a leader,does it matter who,as long as things get done quickly for the suffering people of Haiti.
Is this blog being censored? There are some questionable aspect of C 4 reporting which should be aired, such as:
Your reporter Jon Snow’s repeated badgering of aid agency senior staff ‘Who is co-ordinating the efforts’, repeated about five times, is one of the most miserable sights in C4′s news. This should not be the usual ‘find somebody to blame’ game in the London studio, usual involving a hapless politician. It would be best Jon Snow came back and left those fighting to help the Haitians alone. His reports don’t help anybody. Publicity for the Haitians’ plight? Who does he think he is? And counting the Chinook helicopters at the airport? What IS his point? Cheep anti-yankee stereotyping? Let those actually trying to help do their job, be they Red Cross, UN, US military or Mexican doctors. Reinhard Wentz
Jon-
Fantastic reporting from you and the rest of C4 team. Thank you very much.
Owen
Jon,
Thank you for such sensible reporting…I feel so frustrated watching all those suffering people just struggling to exist! They are in a hostile situation – homes gone, family gone, starving, desperate…this confusion cannot be helping to minimise the lingering shock that Haitians must be experiencing.
Imagine people in Britain trying to cope with any of this Jon? Right now I am so tired of hearing about all the frustrations over the problems caused by flooding, etc…At least there are measures in place to cope with everything in more developed societies. There is so much that we all have to learn from Haiti’s sorrow! I don’t think the world can remain the same after this.
The organisation, or LACK of it is AWFUL! There seems to be a hell of a lot of puffed up bureaucracy with the Americans spending too much time showing off their mighty equipment (aka TOYS). I have a suggestion to make–not sure who will listen, but surely it must be possible and helpful to identify sensible, caring Haitians, other french-speakers who can act as liaisons between all the bodies their to help, (including the obviously frightened military personnel) and the Haitian people?
It’s such a good view and report from you Jon, you just put the things real and show everybody what’s happening. I’ve a friend there, he emailed me outside from the capital and he is saying that to help people there they need to move the mass from the capital areas and take all of them to a open camp and star feed, treat, rescue and start facing the disaster. No one will achieve sucess till they move all this people, the ager, riots, suffering, needed will continue unless we separate the problem from the disaster, we must separate the hunger from the violence and clean the suffering as well as the streets. We can not wait just for food, lets organize a dignity life for those who are suffering and have been so badly damaged. This country needs an organize system and goverment to start giving hope and doing the real job who’s restaurate the country and take it to the first world. It’s a terrible situation inside of the families according with my friend because they have lost the structure of their lifes and under their houses are parents dead. We must face it, the future of this country need profesionalism and an honest leader who build the life so many had lost..
LAUNCH 3s WORLD COUNTRIES LIKE HAITI WILL SOLVE THE PROBLEM OF MANY PEOPLE IN THE WORLD. We need a rule, a new global system that fines the bad goverments when they do bad their jobs, we need to reduce the pregnancy, tag violence, educate them to they solve problems when they are coming. Just wait for US aid will last just 1 month and after? Just people living sad lifes with those goverments who doesn’t know how to do their jobs.
WHY IS THE AID NOT BEING DISTRIBUTED.
Channel 4 has just shown people dying in a temporary camp just yards from the airport perimiter. THIS IS INSANE AND UNACCEPTABLE.
Where are the lessons learnt by aid workers in other crisis about adapting to the situation, culture and practices of the area they arrive in.
TV news has shown people holding up signs outside the airport saying I can drive, I can translate, I will work for food. This aid programme seems to be like some multinational arriving in a different country and never venturing outside of its compound and only employing their own nationals.
We are witnessing the most appalling failure of “sophisticated” western ideas and practices that so much aid is piling up at the airport and not being distributed.
I hope the Haitians go on to liberate the food, water and medical materials they need.
The soldiers should be arresting the profiteers who are holding water supplies to ransom.
This will go down in history as the most shameful failure of intergovernmental co-ordination.
We have been watching with increasing disbelief at the prolonged agony of the victims of the earthquake as immediate aid, food, water and medical help is being flown in but apparently not being distributed.
What is going on?
Haven’t the Americans learnt from their failure after Katrina and no civil society support following the invasion of Iraq that this only increases desperation for survivors. They seem the least suitable people to be in charge.
This isn’t some 5 year plan and where you cant distribute anything until there is a 5 lane highway with rest stops for aid workers, before anything can happen.
Surely it cant be beyond the wit of planners and aid agencies to mobolise appropriate transport for the situation and GET FOOD AND WATER to survivors.
If that means forming a human chain or flying in donkeys to pick their way through the rubble, please, please, can someone with common sense and appropriate knowledge SORT THIS OUT.
Why are the convoys from the Dominican Republic? Why aren’t there camps on the outskirts and leaflets dropped to let people know they’re there?
6 days now and relief is locked behind fences on the airport tarmac. Grotesque.
Stop reporters (who apparently can get round the city) broadcasting what is now becoming disaster pornography of peoples suffering. Go and camp out and dog the steps of those in charge to force them to GET THE AID TO WHERE IT IS NEEDED! NOW – PLEASE!!
If I hear one more high up official say everything has to be in place before they can begin to distribute aid I will scream. I have turned off the news as it is now so distressing and revolting to hear pen pushers come out with theoretical platitudes.
Didn’t they ever go through training excercises where they might just have to face a situation like this.
And as to the constant refrain about the Haitian people being known to react with violence, so this makes it more difficult.
Presumably if there was a disaster in London those of us in Hackney would get no aid as media perceptions of gangs in Hackney would mean no aid worker would set foot in the borough.
At some point news can no be just “neutral reporting”.
The media has the power. Shame them into action.
Every death from lack of medical aid, every death from starvation or de-hydration is a shame on the western “civilised” world.
Why blame the “western civilised world”. The majority of the world is civilised now . You should be blaming the Eastern civilised world for not even partaking in the rescue efforts , or as they are now the biggest entity , the Muslim world.At least the west are trying to do something.When you are looking at least 3 million souls needing help , it is one hell of a logistic effort.
Jon Snow’s reports from Haiti have been marvellous. I was so pleased when he confonted the powers that be about the ridiculous situation at the airport.There is no excuse possible for failing to get aid to those people who are within spitting distance of the airport. It is mightily frustrating to watch. Keep asking the questions, Jon, and alleviate my fury!