Channel 4 FactCheck goes behind the spin to dig out the truth and separate political fact from fiction.

September 16, 2014 No Comments By Patrick Worrall

factfiction108 FactCheck Scotland: has the Scottish government protected the NHS?The claim

“We’ve protected Scotland’s NHS from the Tories’ cuts.”

Alex Neil

The background

The yes campaign says independence is the best way to protect the NHS in Scotland.

But confidential documents passed to the BBC by a senior whistle-blower suggest there is a £400m funding gap on the horizon and the devolved health service will need sweeping reforms to cut costs after the referendum.

The claim has forced the Scottish government to defend its record on running the devolved NHS.

Health Secretary Alex Neil said: “We’ve protected Scotland’s NHS from the Tories’ cuts, and with independence we can ensure that it is never again under threat from Westminster’s dangerous obsession with austerity.”

The analysis

Let’s remember the fundamentals. Westminster gives Scotland a block grant – a lump sum to spend on public services as Holyrood sees fit.

London can and has cut this block grant, leading to overall reductions in the Scottish government’s spending power since 2009/10.

But NHS spending in England has gone up in the same period (slightly) and the Barnett formula means that more spending in England equals more spending in the devolved regions too. It’s up to Scotland how it spends the money that arises from the Barnett system.

The Scottish government says it has protected the NHS budget. Is that true? Well, spending has gone up in cash terms, but not in real terms.

Mr Neil actually switched cleverly between the two in one sentence today when he said: “Despite Scotland’s budget being slashed by 7.2 per cent by George Osborne between 2010/11 and 2015/16, our increases in health spending means that the NHS is receiving record high funding, with a budget increase of over £1bn between 2010/11 and 2015/16.”

The 7.2 per cent cut (to the block grant) is in real terms, but the £1bn increase is in cash, and £1bn over five years is eaten up by inflation.

Last week the Institute for Fiscal Studies said that NHS spending in Scotland fell by 1 per cent in real terms between 2009/10 and 2015/16. In England it went up by 4.4 per cent.

But it’s true the total amount of money allocated to Scotland in the block has gone down, so perhaps the Scottish government had no choice but to cut health spending slightly, given all the other pressures on its budget?

That’s certainly one way of looking at it, but the IFS makes two further points.
16 hospital w FactCheck Scotland: has the Scottish government protected the NHS?

First, Scotland has suffered less from austerity cuts than England: “Over the same period the vagaries of the Barnett formula mean that Scotland will have had to cut overall public service spending by less — by about 8 per cent rather than 13 per cent. But the Scottish government has chosen to protect the NHS in Scotland slightly less than it has been protected in England.”

And the trend of spending less money on Scotland’s NHS than the Barnett formula allows pre-dates the era of austerity:

“This is not a new pattern. Between 2002-03 and 2009-10 – years of plenty for public services rather than cuts – real-terms health spending per person grew by 29 per cent in Scotland compared with a 43 per cent increase across the UK as a whole.

“This was despite overall public service spending per person growing by a very similar amount in Scotland (26 per cent) and the UK as a whole (28 per cent).

“So it seems that historically, at least, Scottish governments in Holyrood have placed less priority on funding the NHS in Scotland (and more on funding other services) than governments in Westminster have for England.”

Other independent research backs this up. This Nuffield Trust-funded study also found that Scottish governments spent less on health than England between 2000/01 and 2012/13, building up a surplus of about £900m to spend on other services.

The verdict

The idea that the Scottish government has bravely struggled to protect the NHS budget under intolerable pressure from Westminster is contradicted by independent research.

The reality is that Scottish governments have for some years chosen to increase health spending by less than it went up in England.

On the other hand, it remains the fact that without independence, Scotland is at the mercy of politicians in London if they want to cut the overall budget for public spending north of the border.

Perhaps the fairest way to sum this up is that there are risks attached to staying in the union and to becoming independent.

The IFS and many others have said that an independent Scotland will face tough spending decisions in the future, thanks to falling oil revenues and an ageing population.

But we know that there are more cuts to Scotland’s block grant on the way under the coalition, and Labour have made a commitment to continuing with a programme of austerity if elected.

By Patrick Worrall

Category: David Cameron, Ed Balls, Ed Miliband, Fact, FactCheck, Fiction, George Osborne, Housing, NHS
Tags: , , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

Are you voting in Scotland on Thursday? Then read this – 10 things you need to know about the referendum vote (but may have been scared to ask).

Category: FactCheck, Scotland
Tags: , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

September 10, 2014 11 Comments By Patrick Worrall

The no campaign has been at great pains to say that a vote to break up the United Kingdom would be irreversible. Is that actually true?

Category: Scotland
Tags: , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

September 4, 2014 21 Comments By Patrick Worrall

Health is one of the key battlegrounds as the independence referendum looks. Will the Scottish NHS be better off in or out of the UK?

Category: FactCheck, Scotland
Tags: , , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

September 1, 2014 18 Comments By Patrick Worrall

Doctors treating Ashya King have defended their decision not to send the five-year-old for proton beam therapy.

Category: FactCheck, Health, NHS
Tags: , ,

Continue reading and comment

August 29, 2014 6 Comments By Patrick Worrall

David Cameron has announced new legislation to stop terror suspects travelling abroad. But can’t we already confiscate their passports?

Category: Conservatives, David Cameron, FactCheck
Tags: , , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

August 28, 2014 12 Comments By Patrick Worrall

How many child grooming gangs are operating on the streets of Britain? Who is most at risk? FactCheck finds out.

Category: FactCheck
Tags: , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

August 26, 2014 7 Comments By Patrick Worrall

The SNP says it wants to rid Scotland of Trident nuclear missiles. Will it be able to keep the promise if Scots vote for independence?

Category: FactCheck
Tags: , , , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

August 25, 2014 14 Comments By Patrick Worrall

It’s ding ding, round two in the Scottish independence debate. Will the leaders of the Yes and No camps fail the FactCheck test?

Category: Scotland
Tags: , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

August 21, 2014 6 Comments By Patrick Worrall

Most teenagers who got their GCSE results today have been told they must stay in education or training until they are 18. But what if they refuse?

Category: Conservatives, David Cameron, Education
Tags: , , , , ,

Continue reading and comment

Top categories

FactCheck contributors